Connect with us

BBC News World

Bowen: A dangerous moment, but US and Israel see opportunity not to be missed

Israel and the US believe Iran’s regime is vulnerable, dealing with an economic crisis and the aftermath of protests.​Israel and the US believe Iran’s regime is vulnerable, dealing with an economic crisis and the aftermath of protests. 

Bowen: A dangerous moment, but US and Israel see opportunity not to be missed

Jeremy BowenInternational editor
Reuters Smoke rises above Tehran after strikeReuters

The decision by the United States and Israel to plunge into a new war with Iran creates a highly dangerous moment with unpredictable consequences. Israel used the word “pre-emptive” to justify its attack.

The evidence is that this is not a response to an imminent threat, which the word pre-emption implies. Instead, it is a war of choice.

Israel and the United States have calculated that the Islamic regime in Iran is vulnerable; dealing with a severe economic crisis, the fallout from the brutal crackdown on protesters at the start of the year and with defences still badly damaged by last summer’s war. Their conclusion seems to have been that this was an opportunity that should not be squandered.

It is also another blow to the tottering system of international law.

In their statements, both President Donald Trump and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that Iran was a danger to their countries – Trump said it was a global danger. The Islamic regime is certainly their bitter enemy. But it is hard to see how the legal justification of self-defence applies given the huge disparity of power between the US and Israel on one side and Iran on the other.

War is a political act. Armed conflict is inherently hard to control once it starts. Leaders need clear objectives.

Benjamin Netanyahu has seen Iran as Israel’s most dangerous enemy for decades. For him, this is a chance to do as much damage as possible to the regime in Tehran and to Iran’s military capacity. Netanyahu also faces a general election later in the year. The evidence from the two years of war with Hamas is that he believes his political position strengthens when Israel is at war.

Donald Trump’s objectives have veered and changed, characteristically. Back in January, he told protesters in Iran that help was on its way. Much of the US Navy was busy removing the leader of Venezuela at the time, so he lacked military options.

While the US was deploying two carrier strike groups to the region, as well as considerable land-based firepower, Trump talked a lot about the dangers of Iran’s nuclear ambitions, even though after last summer’s war, Trump declared that the Iranian nuclear programme had been “obliterated”.

The Iranian regime has always denied that it wants a nuclear weapon, but it has enriched uranium to a level that has no civilian use in a nuclear power programme. At the very least, it seems to want the option of building a bomb. So far Israel and the US have published no evidence that it was about to happen.

In his video, Trump told Iranian people that “the hour of freedom” was at hand. Netanyahu had a similar message, that the war will present the people of Iran with the chance to overthrow the regime. That is not at all certain.

There is no precedent for regime change happening just because of air strikes. Saddam Hussein of Iraq was overthrown in 2003 by a huge US-led invasion force. Muammar Gaddafi of Libya was overthrown in 2011 by rebel forces that were provided with an air force by Nato and some Arab states. In both cases the result was the collapse of the state, civil war and thousands of killings. Libya is still a failed state. Iraq is still dealing with consequences of the invasion and the bloodletting that followed.

Even if this becomes the first case of air power alone collapsing a regime, the Islamic regime will not be replaced by a liberal democracy that upholds human rights. There is no credible alternative government in exile waiting in the wings.

Over almost half a century the Iranian regime has created a complex political system that is underpinned by a mix of ideology, corruption and when required, the ruthless use of force. The Tehran regime demonstrated in January that it was prepared to kill protestors. It has security forces that obey orders to shoot and kill thousands of fellow citizens for challenging the system on the streets and demanding freedom.

Perhaps the US and Israel are trying to kill the supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. Israel believes in the power of assassination as a strategy. In the last two years it killed the leaders of Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in Lebanon, and many of their lieutenants.

The Islamic regime in Iran is a different matter. It presides over a state, not an armed movement. It not a one-man show. If the supreme leader was killed, he would be replaced, most likely by another cleric supported by the Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC), which exists alongside the conventional armed forces with the explicit task of defending the regime against threats at home and abroad.

Trump offered them immunity if they laid down their arms or certain death. The IRGC is unlikely to be tempted by his offer. Martyrdom is a constant motif in the ideology of the Islamic Republic and in Shia Islam.

Trump believes that the primary motivating force in politics and life is transactional – as his book puts it, the art of the deal. But dealing with Iran requires factoring in the power of ideology and belief. That is much harder to measure.

As this crisis has built since the turn of the year, and America assembled its armada, there have been increasing signs that the leadership in Tehran saw war as unavoidable. They engaged in talks, conscious that talks were going on last summer when Israel attacked and the US joined them.

They do not trust the US or the Israelis. In his first term Trump pulled out of the Iran nuclear deal, the JCPOA, which restricted the Iranian nuclear programme and was the marquee foreign policy achievement of the Obama administration.

There have been signs that Iran might have been prepared to accept a JCPOA mark two deal, at the very least to buy time. But the US appears to have also been demanding severe restrictions on its missile programme and its support for regional allies that oppose Israel and the US.

That was unacceptable to them, amounting to a capitulation. Giving up missiles and allies might even in the minds of the leadership make it much more vulnerable to regime change than the threat – and now reality – of attack.

Iran’s leaders will now be calculating how to ride out the war, how to survive and how to manage its consequences. Their neighbours, led by Saudi Arabia, will be dismayed by the huge uncertainty and potential consequences of today’s events.

Given the capacity of the Middle East to export trouble, the eruption of renewed and intensified war deepens the instability of region and wider world that is already turbulent, violent and dangerous.

 

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

BBC News World

G7 nations to hold emergency meeting on oil as stock markets fall

​ G7 nations to hold emergency meeting on oil as stock markets sink. Just now. Faisal Islam,Economics editor,. Peter Hoskinsand. Nick Edser,Business reporters. Anadolu via Getty Images. G7 nations will hold an emergency meeting on Monday to discuss surging oil prices as crudejumped above $100 a barrel and stock markets slumped over the escalating US-Israeli war with Iran.. Finance ministers from leading industrialised countries, including UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves, will gather to discuss the economic impact of the conflict.. Global oil prices reached nearly $120 on Monday over fears of a prolonged disruption to energy supplies through the key Strait of Hormuz shipping route and the UK’s FTSE 100 share index fell 1.3%.. The Financial Times reported the G7 meeting will discuss a joint release of petroleum from reserves, co-ordinated by the International Energy Agency (IEA).. If reserves are released by IEA members it would be the first time since 2022, when action was taken following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.. Major disruption to energy supplies from the region threatens to push up prices for consumers and businesses around the world. Rising inflation could lead to fewer interest rate cuts by central banks.. About a fifth of the world’s oil supply is usually shipped through the Strait of Hormuz. But traffic through the narrow passage has all but halted since the war started more than a week ago.. On Sunday, Iran named Mojtaba Khamenei to succeed his father Ali Khamenei as Supreme Leader, signalling that more than a week into the conflict hardliners remain in charge of the country.. The US and Israel launched fresh waves of airstrikes across Iran over the weekend, hitting multiple targets including oil depots.. Meanwhile, Iran targeted energy infrastructure in neighbouring Gulf states. Overnight, Saudi Arabia said it had intercepted and destroyed two waves of drones heading towards a major oilfield.. Follow the latest developments on the war in the Middle East. Last week the markets had been relatively relaxed about the seemingly nightmare scenario of millions of barrels of crude and liquefied gas trapped in the Gulf, unable or unwilling to transit the Straits of Hormuz.. But the escalations over the weekend, alongside scenes of destruction of energy infrastructure both in Iran and across the Gulf, saw the markets take rapid fright.. On Monday morning in Asia, the price of Brent crude jumped by more than 25% to touch $119.50 a barrel at one point before falling back to around $107.. US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude saw similar movements and was trading at about $104 a barrel.. “The question everyone is asking themselves is, what is the duration of this conflict?” Paul Gooden, head of natural resources at NinetyOne Asset Management, told the BBC’s Today programme.. “The longer it goes on, the more nervous the oil markets are going to be.”. He added that the oil price could rise to a level where “you see so-called demand destructi  

Continue Reading

BBC News World

Guinea opposition leader urges ‘direct resistance’ after 40 parties dissolved

​ Guinea opposition leader urges ‘direct resistance’ after 40 parties dissolved. 43 minutes ago. Jean Otalor. AFP via Getty Images. Guinea’s main opposition leader Cellou Dalein Diallo has said that “direct resistance” to the country’s coup leader–turned–president is now the only remaining path to change, after the authorities dissolved 40 political parties.. The authorities accused the parties of not complying with the law – a charge they have rejected.. The move comes two months after former junta head Mamady Doumbouya was sworn-in as president, following an election that saw some key challengers barred from running.. Doumbouya, who came to power in 2021 after overthrowing Condé, has been accused of cracking down on democratic freedoms.. Among the parties dissolved were the the Rally of the People of Guinea of former President Alpha Condé and Diallo’s Union of Democratic Forces of Guinea. Diallo is currently in exile.. Late last Friday, Guinea’s ministry of territorial administration and decentralisation announced in a decree that the headquarters and local offices of 40 political parties would be closed, and their logos, acronyms and other symbols banned from use.. The parties’ assets have been confiscated and all offices sealed.. The ministry said the parties had failed to comply with legal requirements, including submitting mandatory financial statements. Several of the dissolved groups have rejected the allegations, insisting they met all obligations under the law, the Reuters news agency reported.. In a video statement released on social media on Sunday, Diallo said the decree showed that “war has been openly declared” on those challenging President Doumbouya.. He said political change would not happen through dialogue or democratic processes.. “The head of the junta and his malevolent clique want to rewrite the country’s history by erasing from the political landscape all forces likely to overshadow his nascent one-party state,” he added.. Jean-Marc Telliano, a former minister and president of the Rally for the Integrated Development of Guinea, also criticised the decision. Reuters quoted him as saying that his party would fight to assert its rights and “will use all legal means to have our rights restored”.. More about Guinea from the BBC:. From camouflage to tracksuits – Guinea’s junta leader becomes civilian president. US film stars Meagan Good and Jonathan Majors become Guinea citizens after DNA tests. From Hollywood to the homeland: Why African countries are courting black American stars. Getty Images/BBC. Go to BBCAfrica.com for more news from the African continent.. Follow us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, on Facebook at BBC Africa or on Instagram at bbcafrica. BBC Africa podcasts. Focus on Africa. This Is Africa. Guinea. Africa  

Continue Reading

BBC News World

Australia urged to protect Iran women’s football team as they prepare to fly home

​ Australia urged to protect Iranian football team after Asian Cup elimination. 6 hours ago. Katy Watsonand. Simon Atkinson,reporting from the Gold Coast. Getty. Football’s governing bodies and Australian authorities are being urged to ensure the safety of Iran’s women’s team as they prepare to fly home from Australia after being eliminated from the Asian Cup.. Hundreds of supporters surrounded the Iranian Lionesses’ coach as it left the stadium on the Gold Coast on Sunday evening, with chants of “save our girls”.. Fears for Iran’s women’s team grew after they declined to sing the national anthem ahead of their first match against South Korea last week.. This prompted criticism from within Iran, with one conservative commentator accusing the team of being “wartime traitors” and pushing for harsh punishment.. “We all have very reasonable and serious concerns for their safety,” said Craig Foster, a former captain of the Australian men’s football team and prominent human rights advocate.. He told the BBC: “When any team participates in a Fifa-regulated tournament, whether Asian Football Confederation or any other confederation, they must have the right to safety and external support to express any concerns they have around their safety now or in future.”. In their second match against Australia and then again in Sunday’s final game against the Philippines, the Iranian team sang and saluted during the national anthem, leading critics to believe they’d been forced to take part by members of the ‘Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps accompanying them as part of the delegation.. Deniz Toupchi, who travelled to support the team for their final match, said of the decision to initially stay silent: “We didn’t expect it to be honest because we know it’s a really major [thing] to do.”. She added: “We’re just proud of them.”. Toupchi was one of hundreds of members of Australia’s Iranian community in the stands on Sunday. During the anthem, which they do not recognise, they booed and jeered.. Midway through the first half, many also unfurled the Lion and Sun flag, which served as the official state flag before the Islamic revolution in Iran. These had been snuck into the stadium in defiance of signs outside which said only Iran’s current official flag could be displayed.. But while the fans enthusiastically supported the players, there was very little interaction between them and the team during the match.. In one notable exception, a player receiving medical attention on the sidelines blew a kiss to the stands, receiving a huge cheer.. And while the Filipina team lined up to thank their fans at the end of the match, the Iranians left the pitch promptly.. “They can’t speak freely because they are threatened,” said Naz Safavi, who attended all three matches in which the team played. “We are here to show them that we are fully supporting them.”. Getty. With concern rising over the players’ treatment once they return home, there is a push to support the women to seek  

Continue Reading

BBC News World

N Korea cancels Pyongyang Marathon for ‘some reasons’

​ N Korea cancels Pyongyang Marathon for ‘some reasons’. 1 hour ago. Sofia Ferreira Santos. AFP via Getty Images. North Korea has cancelled the Pyongyang marathon for unspecified reasons, a tour agency linked to the event has said.. British-owned Koryo Tours, which describes itself as the official partner of the marathon, said on Monday that it had received notice of the cancellation from North Korea’s athletics association.. A message it attributed to the association said the marathon was being cancelled “due to some reasons”.. The annual event was established in 1981 to celebrate the birth of North Korea’s founding leader Kim Il Sung. The 2026 race was set to take place on 5 April.. N Korea holds first international marathon in six years. The message, purportedly from the North Korea athletics association’s general secretary, thanked “all the Elite Marathoners and Amateur Runners of the world who are interested in Pyongyang International Marathon”.. The message gave no further explanation on what the reasons for the cancellation were.. Koryo Tours said it understood the decision was final and had been taken “at a level above the organisers of the event itself”.. It said it would be seeking clarification on the circumstances surrounding the decision.. The tour company added that neither organisers nor event partners were involved in making the decision, and said it recognised “this announcement will be disappointing to many runners who had already registered or were planning to participate”.. Koryo Tours, based in Beijing, China, offers several marathon packages to foreigners, departing from Beijing, Shanghai and Shenyang.. Packages start from €2,190 ($2,529; £1,894) for 2.5 nights in the North Korean capital, Pyongyang, including a marathon place and “highlights” of the capital and tickets were sold out this year, according to the agency’s website.. It said all deposits paid will be returned and runners have the option to retain their deposit for a future event or North Korea tour.. A date for the 2027 marathon has not yet been set.. The event had only returned last year after it was suspended for five consecutive years due to the Covid pandemic.. It is open to both amateur and some professional athletes and offers several race distances – 5km (3.1 miles), 10km (6.2 miles), half marathon (21.1km; 13.1 miles) or full marathon (42.2km; 26.2 miles).. Asia. Marathon running. Pyongyang. North Korea  

Continue Reading

BBC News World

Istanbul’s ex-mayor on trial for corruption charges

​ Istanbul’s ex-mayor on trial for corruption charges. 1 hour ago. Alys Davies. AFP via Getty Images. The former mayor of Istanbul has appeared in court asthe central defendant in a mass corruption trial thathis opposition party and rights groups say is politically motivated.. Ekrem Imamoglu, 55, faces more than 140 charges including corruption and running a criminal organisation. Prosecutors are seeking a jail term of up to 2,430 years.. He and his Republican People’s Party (CHP) deny any wrongdoing. They accuse Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and his allies of launching a crackdown over the leader’s decline in popularity.. Prior to the trial, which got off to a chaotic start on Monday, Imamoglu was widely seen as one of the few politicians capable of defeating Erdogan, who has been at the top of Turkish politics since 2003.. Another 407 of Imamoglu’s supporters have also been put on trial, accused of running a criminal corruption network headed by the opposition figure, who prosecutors describe as its “founder and leader”.. Imamoglu was greeted by his supporters with cheers and whistles as he entered the courtroom in the Marmara prison on Monday.. But it was not long before proceedings were brought to a halt by the judge after the politician contested the judge’s decision to hear the testimony of other defendants before his in the trial.. The judge called the protest disrespectful and ordered a recess until the afternoon, just 15 minutes after the hearing had started.. Present in the courtroom were Imamoglu’s wife, Dilek, and CHP leader Ozgur Ozel.. Imamoglu was arrested in March last year on the day he was named as the CHP’s presidential candidate for 2028.. His detention triggered the country’s largest street protests in more than a decade, followed by hundreds of arrests and a police crackdown.. Who is Turkish opposition leader Ekrem Imamoglu?. Turkey moves to silence jailed Erdogan rival by blocking account on X. Apart from the corruption case, prosecutors have accused him of a raft of other offences including espionage and forging his university degree, a qualification he would need to become president and that has since been annulled.. Turkish authorities deny that the judiciary is being used as a political tool.. But the trial has been strongly criticised by rights groups.. “The trial of Mayor Ekrem Imamoglu follows more than a year of weaponising the criminal justice system against his party and other CHP elected officials while he sits in jail,” Benjamin Ward, deputy Europe and Central Asia director at Human Rights Watch, said in a statement last week.. “Looking at these cases as a whole, it’s hard to avoid the conclusion that prosecutors are trying to remove Imamoglu from politics and discredit his party in ways that undermine democracy.”. Amnesty International called the charges brought against Imamoglu “absurd”.. “This politically motivated prosecution, which is based almost entirely on secret witness testimony, is riddled with  

Continue Reading

Latest News

Politics11 minutes ago

‘Steps taken to enhance production’: Hindustan Petroleum after LPG supply hit in India amid US-Iran war

 Hindustan Petroleum said steps are being taken to ensure that cooking gas remains available for households and key public services. 

Politics2 hours ago

Jaipur firm bought Amul items near expiry, tweaked dates to sell, 1.5 lakh kg destroyed: ‘Learnt method on YouTube’

 The operation followed a complaint made via the state government’s 181 helpline regarding suspicious activities, officials said. 

Politics2 hours ago

Jaipur firm bought Amul items near expiry, tweaked dates to sell, 1.5 lakh kg destroyed: ‘Learnt method on YouTube’

 The operation followed a complaint made via the state government’s 181 helpline regarding suspicious activities, officials said. 

Politics2 hours ago

Jaipur firm bought Amul items near expiry, tweaked dates to sell, 1.5 lakh kg destroyed: ‘Learnt method on YouTube’

 The operation followed a complaint made via the state government’s 181 helpline regarding suspicious activities, officials said. 

Politics2 hours ago

Jaipur firm bought Amul items near expiry, tweaked dates to sell, 1.5 lakh kg destroyed: ‘Learnt method on YouTube’

 The operation followed a complaint made via the state government’s 181 helpline regarding suspicious activities, officials said. 

Politics2 hours ago

Madhya Pradesh: Stray cattle to get saffron tags to help manage them better

 Stray cattle were responsible for 237 road accidents, leading to 94 deaths and 133 injuries, according to the State Crime...

Politics3 hours ago

‘Aankh maarta hai’: Rijiju mocks Rahul for 2018 hug & wink in Lok Sabha, gets Priyanka’s retort

 “I’ve never seen such a leader, who hugs the PM, then goes back to his seat and winks at fellow...

Politics5 hours ago

2017 actress assault case: Kerala HC notice to actor Dileep, others on govt appeal

 2017 actress assault case: Kerala HC notice to actor Dileep, others on govt appeal 

Politics6 hours ago

Govt considering lottery system, delinking women’s quota from census, delimitation

 The government is considering implementing the Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam before the 2027 Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand assembly elections 

Politics6 hours ago

Govt considering lottery system, delinking women’s quota from census, delimitation

 The government is considering implementing the Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam before the 2027 Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand assembly elections 

Trending News

Join Our Newsletter

Stay updated with breaking news and exclusive content.